Written by: Jen Wagner
Last updated: January 12, 2025
One of the most common concerns car drivers have involves snow tires. Should you invest in a new set of tires, or can you stick to all-season ones during the winter season? Which option is best?
Well, when it comes down to it, the answer begins with a simple question: Where do you live?
Before you make any decisions, you first need to think about your region’s climate. If temperatures in your area drop to the low 40s or below for an extended period, then investing in winter tires may be a wise—and safe—decision. Continue reading to learn why.
What’s the Difference Between All-Season Tires vs. Winter Tires?
The technology that all-season tires provide is great for drivers who live in moderate climates. They are convenient because they come in different types, sizes, and load capacities. Furthermore, their average tread depths and rubber compounds provide long-lasting tread life.
But when you live where it snows in the winter, the cold temperatures will cause the rubber on all-season tires to harden. As a result, the tire’s ability to grip the road and provide traction will decrease.
Winter tires , however, are more flexible. They have deeper tread depths, patterns, and biting edges. These distinct features help reduce snow and slush buildup, provide more traction, and support the vehicle on the road. But, as winter weather declines and temperatures warm up, the traction softens. When this happens, the tires wear down more quickly.
Therefore, once the weather starts to warm, it is essential to have a certified mechanic remove your winter tires and reinstall your all-season or summer ones. After all, snow/winter tires aren’t cheap, and you don’t want to buy new ones repeatedly because of user error. You want to keep them in good condition and make them last longer.
How Many Winter Tires Do I Need?
A common driving misconception is that you don’t have to install all four winter tires on your vehicle—two are adequate.
This is not true.
While it might seem like a great way to save money, it could actually cost you more in the long run and put you in danger when driving in wintertime conditions.
To begin, only having snow tires on your front wheels will leave your back tires vulnerable to slipping and sliding on the road. Without a proper grip in the rear, your vehicle is susceptible to fishtailing or spinning out when applying your brakes.
Additionally, when you only install snow tires on your rear wheels, you encounter steering control and overhandling issues. Without front snow tires, your car won’t be able to grip the ground well. Installing four winter tires is the best way to keep you safe on the road when you encounter snow, ice, or slushy winter weather conditions—even if you drive an all-wheel SUV or truck.
Can I Damage My Car Using the Wrong Tires?
Installing the proper seasonal tires on your vehicle is just as important as putting on the correct sizes. Automobile manufacturers design and test cars for safety and longevity based on particular tire dimensions. So, say you install too tall or too thin tires. What could possibly happen?
Tires that are too tall for your vehicle could cause it to roll over, resulting in an accident. They could also rub against the inside of your wheel well or cause future steering problems, suspension damage, or accelerated drivetrain wear.
Always be proactive and use a reputable auto shop and technician to ensure you select the best tires for your vehicle and that they are installed correctly. Not doing so could lead to expensive car repairs or replacements for the following parts:
| Transmission | $4,830 – $5,023 |
| Azle shaft | $880 – $959 |
| Suspension shock or strut | $731 – $816 |
| Wheel hub assembly | $406 – $525 |
Estimates derived from RepairPal.com
What Else Should I Do to Keep My Car Running Well?
Aside from using the proper tires, following manufacturer recommendations and safety instructions is equally essential. Failing to do so could void your factory car warranty and leave you having to pay the repair bill out-of-pocket.
Accordingly, stick to the maintenance regime that your manufacturer recommends and track your services by keeping a car maintenance log. Having a comprehensive car maintenance log maximizes your car’s value, which could benefit you in the future.
Should you decide to sell, records of your services will:
- Show buyers that you are dedicated to keeping your vehicle running well
- Assures buyers the car is a good investment
- Confirm any recent services and what they may need to repair or replace in the future
In addition, your car’s tire pressure can change according to the temperature fluctuations outside. Any time the temperatures drop by 10 degrees, your tire can lose one pound of pressure. So as the weather changes, make sure you check the air pressure and add what you need to meet your car’s tire pressure recommendations.
How Can I Protect My Wallet From Big Repair Bills?
If you have further concerns about winter tires vs. all-season, speak to a trustworthy mechanic or contact your dealership for recommendations. They should be able to direct you to the best options for your car and budget. Also, we recommend researching extended warranty options if your vehicle’s factory warranty is no longer active or will be expiring soon.
Without a vehicle protection plan, paying the bill for any repairs your technician makes will be your responsibility. But an extended car warranty from a reputable provider can give you peace of mind when your car needs to visit the repair shop. Protect yourself from unexpected repair bills and hassles down the road by understanding how to pick the right tires, using them properly, and investing in a reliable extended warranty.
Get started today by checking out our extended warranty provider reviews, talking to the providers, and requesting a free quote. You can even compare coverage by reviewing our buying guide.
